CONFERENCE ABSTRACT
“Nobody Sings About It”: In Defense
of the Songs in Caryl Churchill’s Vinegar Tom
by Robert L. Neblett, Washington
University in St. Louis
This performance study examines
the thematic relevance and theatrical potential of the seven songs interspersed
throughout the text of Vinegar Tom, Caryl Churchill’s feminist “play
about witches with no witches in it.” Most critics agree that much of the
play’s feminist message is centralized in the songs; without them, the
play is little more than a historical drama about the Essex witch trials
of the seventeenth century. Nevertheless, few scholars or reviewers have
given much credence to the songs as an integral part of the play in performance.
Although critics do recognize the Brechtian techniques which the songs
utilize, they dismiss the musical numbers as extraneous diversions from
the plot rather than regarding them as “distanced” commentary on Vinegar
Tom’s action. When I directed the play in January 1997 at Washington
University in St. Louis, it was my intent to disprove these contentions
and, in essence, make the songs “work.” In order to do so, I familiarized
myself with Churchill’s own performance theories and the negative critiques
which have become associated with the songs in production. While this paper
is primarily a dramaturgical analysis of the songs in Vinegar Tom,
I employ many examples from my findings as a director of the piece as a
means of defending their intrinsic merit as a necessary component of the
play’s overall dramatic worth, as well as indicating the revolutionary
nature of Churchill’s early theatrical experiments.